Once the matter has been settled and the debtor is within reach and amenable, whether willingly or by legal conviction, the payoff can finally begin. Texas’ laws are meant to protect poor people, who might not be capable of maintaining stable employment, from being convicted or jailed just for being poor. No one wants to live in a world like that. However, the system meant to protect them is used by everyone, even millionaires who wanted a quick pump for their business that didn’t pay off, or rambunctious gamblers that go from state to state leaving loans in their wake.
Once a debt starts to get collected it can be a slow drip to fill the coffers that made it. There are experts who are more accustomed to the process of negotiating money and assets from one pocket to another. An Appointment of a Receiver is a practice where the law firm asks the court to seek out such an expert when the assets themselves are divided up uncommonly or are in values that are difficult to extract.
Someone whose debt was spent on living assets, such as livestock, which has a very tricky depreciation value, or a value that is moot as all the original animals have died, their loan can’t be paid back in bulk animal meat. But there is still value to what they own or owned before, and a Receiver can adjust to that.
The Receiver will work on behalf of the court, not the creditor. They won’t even report directly to the law team who request their appointment. This is not a common practice as it requires the assets to be further split, paying the legal team to seek out their participating and then paying the Receiver to handle the consolidation of the debt. They can be paid up to 25% of the total assets collected. In cases where vast amounts of personal property totalling into the hundreds of thousands, or millions, is involved they may be more useful in getting the things that are hidden from plain sight.
In Texas, certain property is exempt from writs of execution, where the hard assets are liquidated through sales or auctions and the money made is given to the creditors. Debtors can cleverly hide some of their own assets as these exempt properties in order to forego giving them up. A proper Receiver will be able to dispute those claims, and a well practiced law team can find them before a Receiver is needed. The list is quite extensive, though, and important to understand.
1. Homestead
2. Personal property within statutes
3. Wages
4. Prescription health aids
5. Retirement benefits
6. Workers’ Compensation
7. Burial plots
8. Property sold by the Debtor
9. Spendthrift Trust
10. Insurance benefits
11. Alimony & other support
12. Individual Judgements
All but the 12th are guaranteed to remain in ownership of the debtor throughout the judgement. It seems like a lot, but can be reduced down to only a few essential assets that are stipulated to only be able to total up to a certain amount. Understanding the legal difference between what assets can be pursued to equalize the loan and what can’t will allow for the maximum amount of potential collection to be rendered. Even if it’s not the whole amount, it can get close enough.
Spousal property, that which does not belong to the debtor or is in contest of ownership by the debtor’s spouse, is off limits. However, this is also a clever trick. If a debtor surrenders all of their shared assets to their spouse as personal property, gives them up in writing or by some form of legal separation, and has the spouse hold them so they can’t be liquidated, this is legal. But that doesn’t mean it’s right. A good legal team will be able to know when this happens, and can overturn the exception. Then all of the property will be shown as co-owned, and the collections can extend to the “protected property”.
Another way to handle recovery, if the debtor is receiving funding or payment from certain entities, is a Charging Order. While the normal laws can cover employment of welfare benefits, Charging Orders target specific entities and cover scenarios that fall outside of the regular payment models. These situations are usually set up by the debtor to avoid collections being called on their assets, and Charging Orders are there to keep them from breaking the system.
Charging Orders specifically target LLC and Partnership interests where the debtor is being paid via partial ownership or corporate assets by a company they are working for or have been involved with. This can be their own company or a company in which they have invested stock. Corporate stock is a non-exempt type of property which, if it is in a significant amount, can be seized and sold at public auction for the market value in order to recuperate part of the debt. This is one of the ways the creditor can be made into a court-ordered lien holder, but it must go through a Judge to be approved so the assets are not seized unconditionally.
Charging Orders are not meant to replace the whole process, they are meant to cover one specific hole in the system that debtors can exploit, even without knowing it. They only function if and when the exchanges occur, and if a debtor is cut off by a corporation and their stocks are traded prior to a Charging Order being rendered, they cannot be collected. Salaries also aren’t subject to a Charging Order under most circumstances. Assets distributed by companies become non-exempt once they belong to the debtor, meaning that any of them can be withheld until the Charging Order is overturned or the statutes of collections runs out.
Debtors who are partners in LLCs can establish special classifications within the company to help handle asset protection before any such lawsuits are filed. These companies are much harder to collect from as they can create credible deniability of their intent to “hide assets from a creditor” with their own system. However, even if they try to operate out of the system, a proper suit and a quickly timed Charging Order can hinder their ability to collect on or use their liquid cash assets before it can go to a proper creditor. At a certain point it will just be easier for them to pay the creditor than to deal with more and more loopholes their business has to take to keep a little more money between financial quarters.